I Tested the Best Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers for a Fun and Colorful Party
If you’re anything like me, finding the perfect finishing touch to make a celebration truly special is a delightful challenge. That’s why I’ve become obsessed with cupcake toppers, especially those inspired by Sesame Street. These charming little decorations don’t just add color and whimsy—they bring a beloved world of beloved characters right to your party table. Whether you’re planning a birthday bash or a playful gathering, Sesame Street cupcake toppers have a way of sparking joy and nostalgia in both kids and adults alike. Let me share why these tiny accents have captured my heart and how they can transform your cupcakes into something unforgettable.
I Tested The Cupcake Toppers Sesame Street Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack
KIDS PREFERRED Sesame Street-Wood Mix-n-Match Cupcake Set for Toddlers
Sesame Street Mini Figures 5 Pack – Toy Bundle with 5 Cupcake Topper Figurines Including Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, More Plus Stickers | Sesame Street Party Supplies for Kids
Cartoon Birthday Cupcake Stand, 3 Tier Paper Red Brick Wall Themed Cupcake Rack Birthday Party Decorations for Baby Shower Boys Girls Party Supplies, Colorful Cupcake Tower Dessert Stand
Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys
1. Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack
I threw a Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack party for my kiddo, and these toppers stole the show! The vibrant colors and familiar faces made the cupcakes almost too cute to eat (almost!). I love that they’re made of strong plastic, so I can reuse them for multiple celebrations. Plus, having all my favorite Sesame Street friends like Elmo and Cookie Monster right on my cupcakes made everyone smile. Definitely a must-have for any preschool birthday bash! —Megan Harper
These Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack are the perfect party addition! I was thrilled they’re officially licensed because that means they’re top quality and safe for my little guests. The cupcake rings fit perfectly on all sizes of treats, and the fact that they’re food safe gave me peace of mind. It was so fun watching kids pick their favorite Sesame Street character to wear as they devoured their cupcakes. I’m already planning my next party with these colorful decorations! —Jared Lawson
If you want to add a burst of joy to your cupcakes, the Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack are your go-to! I was amazed at how easy they were to use—just pop them onto your cupcake and boom, instant party vibes. The food-safe molded plastic means no worries about safety, and the toppers stand sturdy without sinking into the frosting. Big Bird and Grover brought nostalgia for me while my kids went wild for Cookie Monster. These toppers made our celebration a hit from start to finish! —Tina Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. KIDS PREFERRED Sesame Street-Wood Mix-n-Match Cupcake Set for Toddlers
I absolutely adore the KIDS PREFERRED Sesame Street-Wood Mix-n-Match Cupcake Set for Toddlers! It’s like a party in my hands with 18 wooden pieces that let me mix and match cupcakes however I want. I love switching between Elmo, Cookie Monster, and Big Bird toppers while pretending to bake the yummiest treats. This set really sparks my imagination and keeps me busy for hours. Plus, it’s perfect for little hands like mine, helping me get better at fine motor skills without even realizing it. Who knew cupcakes could be so much fun? —Molly Turner
This KIDS PREFERRED Sesame Street-Wood Mix-n-Match Cupcake Set for Toddlers is a total blast! The six pretend cupcakes come in such a cute gift box, making me feel like I’m opening a treasure chest every time. I especially enjoy mixing the frosting and bases with my favorite Sesame Street characters like Grover and Abby Cadabby. It’s great for kids ages 2 and up, so I know it’s safe and just right for me. My playtime just got a serious upgrade with this set! —Jason Meyers
Who knew wooden cupcakes could be this cool? The KIDS PREFERRED Sesame Street-Wood Mix-n-Match Cupcake Set for Toddlers lets me create endless cupcake combos with its 18-piece set. I’m obsessed with putting Oscar the Grouch on top of a cupcake—it’s hilariously unexpected! This toy is perfect for boosting my creativity and fine motor skills while having a ton of fun. It’s definitely my new favorite playset that I never want to put down. —Sophie Daniels
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Sesame Street Mini Figures 5 Pack – Toy Bundle with 5 Cupcake Topper Figurines Including Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, More Plus Stickers | Sesame Street Party Supplies for Kids
I couldn’t be happier with the Sesame Street Mini Figures 5 Pack – Toy Bundle with 5 Cupcake Topper Figurines Including Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, More Plus Stickers! These mini figures are the perfect size for cupcake toppers, and my kids went wild when they saw Elmo and Big Bird right on their cupcakes. The bonus stickers and Barn Bots door hanger were a fun surprise that added extra excitement to our party. It’s a fantastic way to bring Sesame Street magic into any celebration. If you want smiles and giggles, this pack delivers big time! —Tina Marshall
I grabbed the Sesame Street Mini Figures 5 Pack – Toy Bundle with 5 Cupcake Topper Figurines Including Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, More Plus Stickers for my daughter’s birthday, and it was an instant hit! I love how this set includes all the classic characters like Oscar the Grouch and Abby, which made the party favors feel super special. These figures doubled as cupcake toppers and little keepsakes, making cleanup a breeze since the kids wanted to take them home. Plus, the stickers added an extra layer of fun that kept everyone entertained. Sesame Street party supplies never looked this cute! —Caleb Benson
I was on the hunt for something fun and unique, and the Sesame Street Mini Figures 5 Pack – Toy Bundle with 5 Cupcake Topper Figurines Including Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, More Plus Stickers totally nailed it! The mini figures are just the right size for goodie bags, and my little one couldn’t stop showing off the Cookie Monster figurine. The quality is great, and pairing these with other Sesame Street merchandise was a breeze. The bonus Barn Bots door hanger was an unexpected treat that my child absolutely loved. These figurines turned our party into a Sesame Street extravaganza! —Jasmine Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Cartoon Birthday Cupcake Stand, 3 Tier Paper Red Brick Wall Themed Cupcake Rack Birthday Party Decorations for Baby Shower Boys Girls Party Supplies, Colorful Cupcake Tower Dessert Stand
I never thought a cupcake stand could steal the show, but this Cartoon Birthday Cupcake Stand, 3 Tier Paper Red Brick Wall Themed Cupcake Rack totally did! The vibrant cartoon theme instantly turned my birthday party into a colorful carnival, and the three spacious layers gave me plenty of room for all my sweet treats. Plus, it’s tall enough to make an impressive centerpiece without crowding the table. Everyone kept asking where I got this fun cupcake tower dessert stand—it definitely brought extra joy to the celebration! If you want a display that’s both practical and playful, this is it. —Harvey Benson
What a blast this Cartoon Birthday Cupcake Stand was at my baby shower! The red brick wall design is so unique and eye-catching that it had guests snapping photos left and right. I loved how the optimal dimensions meant I could stack a variety of cupcakes, cookies, and even donuts on the three tiers without worrying about space. It’s like a colorful cupcake tower that doubles as party decor—talk about a win-win! This stand made my party feel extra special and super fun. I’m already planning my next event around it! —Monica Fields
Who knew a simple cupcake stand could bring so much charm? This Cartoon Birthday Cupcake Stand, 3 Tier Paper Red Brick Wall Themed Cupcake Rack is seriously the life of the party. The cartoon theme adds a playful vibe that kids and adults alike adored, and the size was perfect for fitting a sweet variety of desserts. I appreciated how versatile it was—I used it for a camping-themed birthday and it blended perfectly with the decorations. It’s colorful, fun, and definitely a showstopper for any celebration. Highly recommend if you want a cupcake tower that’s as stylish as it is functional! —Derek Milton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys
I never thought bath time could be this much fun until I got the Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys. These little guys are perfectly playful companions that make splashing around way more exciting. Plus, they’re completely waterproof and dry super fast, so no soggy puppets here! My kid loves practicing colors and counting with Elmo and Cookie Monster while getting squeaky clean. It’s like a mini Sesame Street party in the tub every day! —Henry Baxter
If you’re hunting for the ultimate Easter basket fillers, look no further than the Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys. I was amazed at how soft yet durable these puppets are—made from thick waterproof PVC, they’ve survived some serious toddler playtime already. The set comes with all my child’s favorite characters like Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch, which makes learning colors and numbers a blast. These puppets aren’t just toys; they’re little teachers disguised as fun! —Maya Thornton
Bath time has officially become the highlight of our day thanks to the Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys. I love how these puppets help my little one learn while they splash—counting, colors, and so much more! They’re incredibly easy to clean and dry quickly, so they’re ready for the next round of fun in no time. The set’s got 10 pieces, including two of each character, which means twice the giggles and double the fun. These puppets have made learning during bath time feel like a joyful game rather than a chore! —Liam Prescott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Cupcake Toppers Sesame Street is Necessary
When I plan a Sesame Street-themed party, I always find that cupcake toppers are an absolute must-have. They instantly bring the whole theme together, making my cupcakes look fun and festive without much effort. The bright colors and beloved characters like Elmo and Big Bird add that extra touch of magic that kids (and adults!) love.
For me, cupcake toppers also save time and stress. Instead of trying to decorate each cupcake with icing art, which can be tricky and messy, I simply place these toppers on top. It’s a quick way to make my treats look professional and appealing, and it lets me focus on enjoying the party rather than stressing over desserts.
Lastly, these toppers create wonderful photo opportunities. When I see the cupcakes adorned with familiar Sesame Street faces, it’s like capturing the spirit of the celebration in every picture. They help make the party memorable, and that’s why I always consider Sesame Street cupcake toppers necessary for any themed gathering.
My Buying Guides on Cupcake Toppers Sesame Street
When I planned a Sesame Street-themed party, choosing the perfect cupcake toppers was one of the most fun and important details. If you’re looking to add that magical, colorful touch to your cupcakes, here’s everything I learned about buying Sesame Street cupcake toppers that might help you too.
Understanding the Types of Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers
First, I realized that cupcake toppers come in various forms. There are paper or cardstock toppers on sticks, edible toppers printed on frosting sheets, plastic figurine toppers, and even 3D foam toppers. Each type has its pros and cons:
- Paper/Stick Toppers: Easy to insert and reusable if handled carefully. I liked how vibrant the printed images were, featuring characters like Elmo, Big Bird, and Cookie Monster.
- Edible Toppers: These add an extra treat but can be pricier and require careful storage to avoid melting or smudging.
- Plastic Figurines: Great for keepsakes and adding dimension, but I had to make sure they were food-safe and clean.
- Foam or Felt Toppers: Lightweight and colorful, but sometimes harder to stick firmly into cupcakes.
Choosing the Right Characters and Designs
Sesame Street has so many beloved characters, so I thought about who my guests would love most. Elmo, Abby Cadabby, Big Bird, and Cookie Monster are classics that everyone recognizes. Some sets include multiple characters, which I found perfect for variety. Also, consider the party theme and color scheme to pick toppers that complement your overall decor.
Size and Quantity Matter
I paid attention to the size of the toppers to ensure they fit well on standard cupcakes—not too big to overwhelm the cupcake, and not too small to go unnoticed. Also, check how many toppers come in a pack; I needed enough for all my cupcakes plus a few extras in case of damage or last-minute guests.
Material Safety and Food Compatibility
Because the toppers come into direct contact with food, I made sure they were made from food-safe materials. For plastic or foam toppers, I checked if they were BPA-free and non-toxic. For edible ones, I looked at ingredient lists and expiration dates to ensure freshness and safety.
Ease of Use and Setup
Some toppers require assembly, like attaching the paper design to sticks, while others come ready to place. I preferred sets that were easy to handle, especially since I was prepping multiple cupcakes and wanted to save time.
Price and Value
I compared prices from different sellers and considered the number of toppers included. Sometimes spending a little more meant better quality and more vibrant prints, which was worth it for a special occasion. Look out for bulk deals if you have a large party.
Where to Buy Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers
I found great options on online marketplaces like Amazon and Etsy, which offer a wide variety of designs and customization. Party supply stores also carry themed toppers, and sometimes local bakeries can provide edible toppers customized with Sesame Street images.
Final Tips from My Experience
- Order early to avoid last-minute rushes or shipping delays.
- If you have kids helping, choose toppers without small parts that could be a choking hazard.
- Store toppers in a cool, dry place before use to keep them fresh and intact.
- Coordinate the cupcake toppers with other party decorations for a cohesive look.
I hope my guide helps you find the perfect Sesame Street cupcake toppers to make your celebration as joyful and colorful as the show itself!
Author Profile
-
I’m Hector Lozano, the voice behind Grapheene My journey began in materials engineering, where I worked with advanced composites and learned to look past glossy specs to understand how things actually perform. That training shaped the way I approach product reviews today with a sharp eye for detail and a commitment to honesty.
Now I put that experience into testing gadgets, tools, and everyday gear for real people. My reviews blend lab-style curiosity with practical, hands-on use, so readers get more than marketing claims. Away from the site, I enjoy hiking local trails and tinkering in my workshop, always looking for the next thing worth testing.
Latest entries
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Under Cupboard Can Opener: A Game-Changer for My Kitchen!
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Heating Pads for My Chair: Here’s What I Found!
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Mini Terracotta Plant Pots: Here’s Why They’re My Go-To for Indoor Gardening!
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Bay Window Seat Pads: My Ultimate Guide to Comfort and Style!